In the mortgage industry, everyone is graded. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) grades the lender. The lender grades the title company. The title company grades the signing companies. The title companies and signing companies grade the Notary Signing Agents. This is how the industry makes sure everything is being done according to government regulations and contractual obligations.
Of course, the businesses and contractors that get the best grades get the most work. So how do you, as an NSA, earn and retain a high rating?
Be Responsive
It isn’t always easy to answer the phone or respond to a text immediately. That’s understandable. Companies just want a Notary to respond regardless of whether the answer is “Yes, I can” or “No, I can’t.” Not everyone does a mass cattle call. Some wait for a response before moving on to the next person. You shouldn’t be downgraded for saying “no” but you might if you only ever respond when it’s a “yes.”
Be Prompt
Do your best to be on time for a signing. Delays happen, sometimes through no fault of yours. Just keep all parties apprised of the situation. Title companies don’t want to receive a phone call wondering where you are, and they definitely don’t want the lender calling them to find out.
Be Professional
In both attitude and appearance, you represent the lender and title company. No matter where you are or how others act, you are conducting serious business and you should always act and dress in a manner befitting the situation. I have seen Notaries placed on a “do not use” list for wearing jeans and sneakers to a closing.
Double Check Your Work
This goes without saying but just glance through your package one last time before returning it. One mistake isn’t likely to cause your rating much detriment. Repeated mistakes will. Where most Notaries get downgraded is the length of time it takes them to correct the mistake. Getting that error corrected should take precedence over anything else in your schedule. I have a customer who tracks not only every mistake but how long it takes to get the correction back to them. The longer it takes, the lower my rating.
Follow Directions
The vast majority of the time, when a Notary gets downgraded, it’s because they didn’t follow directions. That includes not collecting two forms of ID, not faxing and not returning the correct number of copies. I have heard NSAs say countless times that they didn’t do something because they didn’t feel it was necessary. You may not know the reasoning, but it is part of the job you accepted. It is only proper to complete that job in its entirety.
As a Notary, you have a right to know your rating and how to improve it. Instead of asking your customers for more signings, ask them how you can do a better job for them. Increased signings will be a byproduct of improved performance.
Not all rating systems are the same, but most companies evaluate Notary Signing Agents on a few key factors: accuracy, timeliness, professionalism, and communication. These ratings directly impact how much work you’re offered, so it’s important to know what they’re looking for. Some companies track metrics like response times or error rates, while others might simply rely on feedback from borrowers or title companies. By understanding how you’re being graded, you can adjust your practices to meet expectations and ensure you stay at the top of their list.
Clear communication is a cornerstone of maintaining a high rating as an NSA. Always confirm appointment details promptly, notify companies immediately of any issues, and keep all parties informed if delays occur. Don’t be afraid to ask for feedback after a signing—it shows you’re committed to improving. Instead of simply asking for more assignments, try asking, “What can I do to better meet your needs?” This proactive approach not only helps you improve but also strengthens your relationship with the companies you work with.
Marcy Tiberio is a NNA 2015 Notary of the Year Honoree and owner of Professional Notary Services, Inc., in Rochester, New York. She can be reached at marcy@professionalnotaryservices.biz.
Related Articles:
5 mistakes that cost mobile Notaries time and money
Score Notary signing assignments like a pro
Additional Resources:
Signing Agent Tools
Signing Professionals Workgroup